Wed, Nov 11

Pennsylvania’s December 1 Default-Rate Reset: Why the Price to Compare Is Climbing Again

On December 1, Pennsylvania’s electric distribution utilities reset their default-service rate — the Price to Compare. The filings are in: PPL Electric has proposed roughly a 10% increase and PECO roughly 11%, both pending PUC approval. The Commission is already alerting consumers.

It’s worth being precise about what’s moving. Default service isn’t a utility-set retail price; it’s competitively procured on a rolling schedule, and the Price to Compare is essentially a pass-through of wholesale and capacity costs. Recent PJM capacity-auction clearing prices — well above prior years — feed into these default-service resets on a lag. So a December 1 increase isn’t a sudden policy choice; it’s months-old market cost surfacing on a scheduled date.

For anyone tracking default-service load, acquisition, or retention, each reset is a migration event. When the Price to Compare jumps double digits, the spread between default service and competitive fixed offers widens, and shopping activity rises in the weeks around the reset. Pennsylvania’s two reset dates — June 1 and December 1 — are the moments the economics of shopping visibly change, and migration tends to follow the spread.

The practical read: default-service customers who treat December 1 as a date to act on, rather than a surprise to absorb, are the ones who capture the spread. The ones who don’t simply inherit whatever the market cleared at — which, this winter, is higher.

Default service is doing exactly what it’s designed to do. The open question, every reset, is how many customers notice in time to do anything about it.

1