Yesterday, the New York Times ran this story about a bill called BAAJA that’s been bouncing around the House of Representatives for months and has strong support from both parties (yes, you heard that right…both parties). It’s to address a problem that’s been around for years: Builders of energy projects like new power transmission lines and gas pipelines require years just to receive the permits they need to start construction on their projects.
Some of the delays are due to legitimate local opposition, for example when a new data center is accompanied by a highly polluting power plant. This happened in South Memphis and northern Mississippi, when xAI installed highly polluting methane gas turbines to “temporarily” power its Colossus data center. This is still being litigated, although of course the turbines are turning as I write this.
But at least some of the delays are due to outdated laws and bureaucratic inertia; this bill tries to walk the fine line between allowing legitimate objections to be considered and reducing paperwork requirements that allegedly produce little or no benefit. The only way a bill like this can work is if both sides can negotiate and reach a fair compromise. I define that as a deal in which both parties are unhappy, but neither is unhappy enough to block the deal entirely.
One reason why this bill is bipartisan is that it addresses just about the only provision that can unify all factions: it paves the way for hefty power bills to be paid by data center developers. One big lesson from the midterms is there’s just one town in the US – Harwood ND, population 940 – that actually wants a data center to be built there. Or maybe I should put it this way: I’m amazed there’s even one town in the US that still likes data centers. Presumably Harwood has a lot of land around it, where it’s possible to “grow” data centers more profitably than winter wheat. But 44 of the 45 data center ballot initiatives during the midterms failed.
What exactly does this bill do regarding data centers? The article says, “One measure would direct the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to issue new rules within 90 days that would charge data centers both the costs of any grid upgrades needed to serve them and the costs of using the existing electrical network.” This potentially could require data centers to pay twice for grid upgrades needed to serve them.
This might sound unfair, but the problem is that data centers impose costs on their communities that go well beyond the costs of producing and transmitting the power they consume. These additional costs include heavy water usage, clogged roads, air pollution, and more. Data centers should pay a much higher rate because of those “externalities” (although additional money should also go to local governments, which must bear a lot of these costs).
The article estimates that this and other provisions could require data center operators to pay up to $170 Billion more for the power they use over the next ten years. While I doubt even that amount would pay for all the externalities, it would certainly be a big improvement over today. Thus, I was strongly inclined to support the bill…
Until I read this paragraph at the end: “The permitting bill could make it harder for environmental groups to sue to block those projects by scaling back laws like the National Environmental Policy Act and the National Historic Preservation Act. It could also hinder future presidents from rescinding federal permits for data centers or imposing a moratorium on public lands.”
And especially until I read the 2-page document linked in that paragraph. That document from the Wilderness Society includes these paragraphs:
“Sec. 1401 would lock in authorizations and permits by preventing future administrations from taking any action on permitted projects on public lands, even when permits were approved unlawfully, except under extremely limited circumstances.”
“If passed in its current form, this means permanently entrenching data center development on public lands. With at least 35 data center related applications covering 24,000 acres of public lands already pending, this could have very damaging impacts for public lands and local communities.”
“Sec. 1402 could make a data center moratorium on public lands exceedingly difficult to implement and could allow developers to sue taxpayers if their projects are slowed.”
“The provision could be weaponized against a future administration that might try to deprioritize harmful developments like fossil fuel projects that power data centers.”
“This bill strips safeguards for water pollution by reducing protections in the Clean Water Act (CWA) section 404 dredge and fill program, the only federal framework that protects wetlands and other waters. The bill would remove the EPA’s ability to veto the most egregious projects and ignore impacts on wildlife, flood control and other critical values.”
Of course, I’m sure the objectionable provisions could be renegotiated. However, there isn’t time for that, given that Congress will be in session no more than three weeks this year; it’s much better to wait until next year to reopen negotiations. But there’s an even more important reason why it’s better to wait: The next Congress will include many more friends of the environment, as well as people who are skeptical of the idea that the number one priority of the US should be “winning” (whatever that means) the AI war with China, no matter the cost to the environment, the power grid, public health, affordability, etc.
The cavalry is coming. Let’s wait for them to arrive.
Tom Alrich’s Blog, too is a reader-supported publication. You can view new posts for three months after they come out by becoming a free subscriber. You can also access all of my 1300 existing posts dating back to 2013, as well as support my work, by becoming a paid subscriber for $30 for one year (and if you feel so inclined, you can become a founding subscriber for $100). Whether free or paid, please subscribe. Of course, if you can’t afford the $30, please email me and I’ll give you a complimentary one-year full subscription (this offer doesn’t apply to bots).
If you would like to comment on what you have read here, I would love to hear from you. Please comment in my chat or email me at [email protected].