Tue, Nov 17
Partner Content

AI Readiness in Electric Utilities: From Deployment to Operating Value

Utilities are moving past artificial intelligence (AI) experimentation, but many have not yet built the operating discipline required to convert AI activity into measurable value. AI is already supporting field operations, asset health, work management, customer service, and knowledge work. The more important question is how that activity will translate into sustained operating value.

ScottMadden’s nuclear AI landscape review identified more than 60 AI deployments across utility and nuclear operations. Nuclear is relatively far along in putting AI into practical use, yet roughly 60% of the deployments tracked were active without a quantified operating benefit attached to them.¹ This reflects a gap in documented benefits, not necessarily in value delivered.

Broader sector research points in the same direction. Just over half of utilities report positive returns on AI investment, while 56% of energy leaders say they struggle to connect productivity improvements directly to AI efforts.²,³

Operating value should be expressed in terms the business already manages: reliability, safety, cycle time, labor capacity, cost, quality, customer outcomes, or risk reduction. Usage statistics and model performance may support the story, but they are not substitutes for an agreed operating baseline and a measurable change in results. Defining that connection early gives the pilot a decision to support rather than simply a technology to demonstrate.

Closing that gap takes more than a list of use cases. It takes clarity on what the use case is worth, who owns the outcome, whether the data and controls fit, whether the workforce will use it, and whether the funding survives the pilot.

Why Technically Viable Use Cases Still Stall

The electric power industry has seen this pattern with other digital technologies. A tool can perform as designed and still fail to change operating results. The constraint is often the organization around technology: the process it must enter, the person accountable for the outcome, the data and systems it must use, and the workforce expected to trust it.

AI sharpens these challenges. A model can degrade without an obvious equipment failure, produce outputs that are difficult to explain, or cross boundaries among operations, information technology, operational technology, vendors, and business functions. Those characteristics matter, but they should remain tied to the operating objective. Governance for its own sake does not create value.

Use cases typically stall for four reasons:

  • The problem was never defined. A promising capability is selected before the operating decision, process, baseline, or target outcome is defined.

  • Ownership is fragmented. The technology team can deliver a pilot, but no business owner is accountable for changing the process, accepting the output, and sustaining performance.

  • Integration begins too late. Production planning surfaces data access, workflow, architecture, vendor, and control requirements that were outside the proof of concept.

  • Users are brought in too late. Operators and frontline staff hear about the tool once the design decisions are made rather than shape how it fits their work.

Someone must change the procedure, accept the output as a legitimate input, and decide whether the old way of working goes away. That work sits outside the team building the tool, which is usually why it doesn't happen.

Five AI Readiness Dimensions That Connect AI Deployment to Value

Readiness does not mean every enterprise capability must be mature before work begins. It means knowing what a specific use case needs, what can be built during experimentation, and what must be resolved before production.

Five dimensions decide whether a use case converts:


How Readiness Enables the Next Decision

The purpose of readiness work is not to delay experimentation until conditions are perfect. It is to make the next decision explicit. A use case can proceed, proceed while specific foundations and safeguards are developed in parallel, or pause until a material gap closes. The answer depends on what the application touches, what happens if it fails, and whether the organization can detect and manage that failure.

The same discipline sharpens pilot design. A pilot should test the value hypothesis and the operating assumptions that matter most, not only technical performance: whether users can interpret the output, whether the source data is available at the required frequency, whether the recommendation fits the existing decision window, and whether the organization can measure the outcome. Findings then shape the production plan while the design is still flexible.

It also improves portfolio decisions. Utilities can prioritize use cases that combine meaningful operating value with a practical path to integration and adoption. Higher-consequence opportunities may still warrant investment, but their business cases should reflect the additional work required to deploy them responsibly.

ScottMadden Solutions Across the AI Continuum

ScottMadden helps utilities move from AI opportunity identification through sustained operating value. The services below can be engaged individually, but we connect them so that decisions, requirements, evidence, and ownership carry forward across the full AI life cycle.

  • AI Strategy and Use Case Prioritization. Identify where AI can improve a real operating process, compare opportunities based on value, feasibility, and operating fit, and establish a sequenced portfolio.

  • Readiness and Risk. Evaluate the business, process, data, workforce, funding, integration, and risk conditions required for the use case to advance, including which gaps can close during experimentation and which must be addressed before production.

  • Experimentation. Design focused experiments around measurable success criteria while advancing the organizational and technical foundations needed for implementation. Establish clear gates for continuing, adjusting, or stopping the effort.

  • Integration and Operating Model. Translate the pilot into an operating process by defining workflows, system connections, vendor requirements, controls, accountability, support, and ownership after implementation.

  • Change, Training, and Adoption. Engage operators and frontline users in design and testing, update procedures and roles, provide training on the system’s purpose and limits, and build the trust and feedback mechanisms needed for sustained use.

  • Value Measurement and Scale. Measure operating performance against the original baseline and value case, then determine whether to scale, adjust, or stop the application based on demonstrated results.

How the Continuum Enables Value

The services operate as a connected continuum. Strategy establishes why an opportunity matters. Readiness defines what must be true for it to advance. The pilot produces evidence about value and feasibility. Integration turns that evidence into a functioning operating process. Change and training prepare the organization to use it. Measurement determines whether the application should scale. Lessons from each stage inform the decisions that follow and can redirect earlier assumptions before they become expensive.

ScottMadden can support the full continuum or target the stages where a utility needs an independent bridge among operations, business ownership, technology delivery, risk management, and organizational adoption. We do not need to be the model builder to help the client define requirements, challenge vendor claims, establish acceptance criteria, and keep implementation centered on the operating outcome.

References

1. ScottMadden, “AI in Nuclear Operations: The Shift from Adoption to Operating Value.”

2. Kyndryl, “How AI Is Reshaping Utilities and the Power Grid,” February 2026.

3. EY, “Energy Cautiously Enters the Next Stage of AI Adoption,” December 2025.

1