Utility Search Marketplace graphic titled “Everyone Blames the Data Center. The Data Says Look at the Wires,” under the kicker “What’s actually driving your bill.” Subtext: distribution build-out, disaster recovery and gas prices — not large loads — moved rates most over 2019–2025. Source: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2025. Three transmission towers with connecting power lines illustrate the point, the center tower highlighted in orange.
For a year, one explanation has dominated every conversation about rising electric bills: data centers. It’s the cable-news headline, the town-hall villain, and increasingly the target of legislation. It’s also, according to the data on the last five years, mostly not what happened.
A Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory analysis released this fall — the most comprehensive look yet at what actually moved residential rates — found the largest correlates of rising prices weren’t large loads at all. They were the poles and wires. Distribution capital spending rose roughly 50% between 2019 and 2023 and now makes up about half of all utility spending. Disaster and wildfire recovery added as much as 4 cents per kilowatt-hour in California. Natural gas price swings after 2022 lifted rates about a cent in the most gas-exposed states. Data center demand, over that period, wasn’t a primary driver — and in a detail that cuts against the whole narrative, states where electricity sales grew tended to see prices fall, not rise.
Two honest caveats keep this from being a victory lap. First, it’s a correlation study; its authors are careful to say it doesn’t prove cause. Second, it’s a rear-view mirror. The same researchers warn that data center demand could outrun supply and infrastructure and push prices up from here — and in parts of PJM, wholesale and transmission costs are already feeling it. The data-center story isn’t wrong. It’s early.
This distinction matters because it’s now driving policy. ScottMadden’s latest Energy Industry Update, which surfaced much of this, documents affordability moving from a regulatory question to a political one: in January, New Jersey’s governor declared an affordability emergency and moved to freeze rate increases. Expect more of that, in more states.
For anyone actually paying the bill, there’s a more useful takeaway than finding a villain. The increase that traces to distribution, transmission, and disaster recovery lives on the regulated side of the bill — the half a customer in a competitive market can’t shop. The supply rate they can shop is real money, but it’s not where most of this decade’s increase came from. Knowing which half moved is the first step to doing anything about the half you control.