The mission of this group is to bring together utility professionals in the power industry who are in the thick of the digital utility transformation. 

27,227 Members

WARNING: SIGN-IN

You need to be a member of Energy Central to access some features and content. Please or register to continue.

Post

Modeling future changes in microgrids

Image of CA-PV and thermal used with permission

The fundamental benefits of distributed energy are becoming more apparent, in very official ways, to governments, utilities and other entities involved in power generation and management. This is spurring investment in microgrids and grid-tied distributed energy projects, in the form of national goals for hybrid renewable microgrids, commitments to building thousands of distributed energy systems, generous incentives, large grants by international development agencies and new regulations that encourage distributed energy investment. 

Last year, the share of new global energy added by distributed generation exceeded the amount added by new centralized power plants for the first time ever. According to Navigant Research, by 2026, microgrids are expected to supply three times more new power to the grid than centralized generation resources. The microgrid market is expected to reach $30 billion early in the next decade. Meanwhile, the International Energy Agency estimates that one third of all new power connections – presumably for people who currently have no access to electricity – will be enabled by microgrids, with most of those, nearly 300 million, in Africa and India.

So, it’s clear that we’re looking at an explosion of growth in microgrid technology. And already, energy experts are wondering what comes next. How will these yet-to-be-built microgrids adjust to changes in local circumstances such as population, load growth, and changes to energy prices? How will battery and PV panel degradation impact the system performance? These are different problems, but we need to start thinking about how to ensure that distributed energy projects can adapt to change in cost-effective ways.

Because, while electricity demand is leveling off in developed countries and creating financial headaches for utility managers, the developing world is another story. We can already predict that rapid growth in power needs will take place as energy access becomes widespread. For example, in sub-Saharan Africa and India especially, millions of people who have traditionally had no access to electricity whatsoever are now enjoying the benefits of compact solar home systems that provide small amounts of lighting for children to do their homework, for parents to charge their cell phones, and for small shopkeepers to stay open into the evening hours.

But soon, after a brief exposure to the miracle of electricity, the people in these communities will be striving to develop small businesses, and wondering how their electric resources can support more diverse and economically productive end uses. That means scaling up from solar home systems to microgrids, especially ones that provide better power quality than the central grid.

Microgrids / Minigrid Modularity

Now that microgrids and mini-grids are moving from single grant-funded pilot projects to portfolios of commercially financed systems, cost-effectiveness is the key to success for these promising technologies. Finding the least cost solution has always been the focus of the HOMER® software. Unlike the island utility market or the behind-the-meter market where there is measured load data, the energy access market has a further challenge because both the initial load is uncertain and the rate at which it will grow is even more difficult to anticipate.

Most energy access developers put a lot of effort into surveys of their customers about what appliances they expect to have and how much they will use them. In one Haitian project the designers installed a diesel-powered microgrid for an entire year, just to collect accurate load data before using HOMER Pro to model and develop the hybrid renewable project. To further complicate things, it is inherently difficult to predict what people who have not had electricity will do when they get it. Experience has shown that with the advent of reliable electricity, some villages rapidly expand their use, causing the load on the system to increase quickly.

Many funding agencies address this challenge by overbuilding the system in the first place. This is a logical solution given their financial aid processes because it is often much easier to get funding to build a new system than to expand an existing one. However, for a commercially-financed developer, the extra cost of overbuilding jeopardizes their financial viability.

Modular design is an obvious solution, especially since solar panels and batteries are inherently modular. Modularity allows the system to be expanded as needed, but it is not as easy as it sounds. Even though solar panels and batteries have modular characteristics, they are deployed in strings, and each panel or battery in the string must be similar. You cannot mix new batteries with old batteries in the same string. Even mixing them in separate strings requires controls and power conditioning equipment designed for that. Not all inverters and controllers can handle this, but it is promising to see the industry move in this direction.

About HOMER Energy

This content was provided by HOMER Energy, the developer and distributor of the HOMER software, the global standard for energy modeling tools that analyze solar-plus-storage microgrids and other distributed energy projects. HOMER software determines engineering and economic feasibility by simulating complex off-grid and grid-tied distributed energy systems that combine conventional and renewable power, storage, and load management. Learn more at www.homerenergy.com, and read more content like this at www.microgridnews.com.

Dr. Peter Lilienthal's picture

Thank Dr. Peter for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.

Discussions

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on May 19, 2019 3:08 pm GMT

Peter, what advantages do microgrids offer over centralized generation? They don't have a great track record for reliability:

"VIEQUES, Puerto Rico―It looks like something out of a brochure advertising what renewable energy could offer a remote, storm-ravaged island.

Workers from Tesla, billionaire Elon Musk’s electric car and solar energy giant, arrived on Vieques just weeks after hurricanes Irma and María crippled the aging electrical grid and severed the transmission cable that connected this island to the Puerto Rico mainland seven miles west. The company selected the senior center as one of 11 sites on the darkened island that it would equip with power-producing panels and batteries.

'It doesn’t work,' a nurse at the senior center said in Spanish during a HuffPost visit in late February. 'It never has.'

Today the island still depends on dirty power from the mainland, and some solar panels and batteries sit useless and broken with another hurricane season less than a month away."

 

Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on May 20, 2019 10:21 am GMT

Microgrids are a technological solution that opens up possibilities and flexibility that can greatly benefit these island & remote communities. However, like any technology they need to be implemented soundly to provide those benefits. While your links shows an instance where unfortunately hasn't affected the change that the tech is possible of, there are many more case studies on the other side.

I'd recommend this study from Rocky Mountain Institute that covers 10 successful case studies:

Leading islands and remote communities, from the deserts of Australia to the isles of the United Kingdom, have already transitioned from 100 percent oil-based electricity systems to ones with significant renewable penetration. These communities are enjoying the many benefits that come with the transition: operational cost savings, reliable and stable power, long term energy price stability, and reduced dependence on oil.

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »