Skip to content Skip to navigation

Intelligent insights & conversations with global power industry professionals

  • ×
  • Create new content
    • Sign In
    • Apply for Membership
  • News
  • Communities
    • The Power Industry Network™

      Utility Business Network
      EnergyBiz® Network
      • Utility Professionals
      • Utility Management 
      • Customer Care 
      • HR & Recruitment
      • Resource Management
      Generation Network
      Generation Network
      • Generation Professionals
      • Clean Power Group
      Energy Management Network
      Energy Management Network
      • Load Management
      • Energy Efficiency
      Intelligent Utility Network
      Intelligent Utility® Network
      • Digital Utility
      • Mobile Workforce
      Grid Network
      Grid Network
      • Grid Professionals
      • Transmission Professionals
      Energy & Sustainability Network
      Energy & Sustainability
      Network
      • The Energy Collective
      • Oil & Gas Professionals
      • Clean Energy Business Network
      • Enel Foundation
  • Industry
    • Posts
    • Q&A
    • Members
    • Experts
    • Topics
    • Events
    • Resources
  • Jobs
  • Sponsors
  • Subscribe
  • More
    • Posts
    • Q&A
    • Members
    • Experts
    • Jobs
    • Topics
    • Resources
    • Sponsors
    • Subscribe
Part of Energy Management Network »

Energy Efficiency Group

In partnership with AESP: The increasing roles of DERs, connected technology and Big Data are driving rapid change in energy efficiency. As we shape the Utility of the future, this community will help you keep up with the latest developments. 

11,783 Members
Join
Follow via RSS
  • Home
  • Posts
  • Q&A
  • News
  • Members
  • Experts
  • Sponsors

Author Profile

Ben Schultz's picture
Ben Schultz
Owner Deluxe Copywriting
Follow
Contact

About me

Ben is an Australian freelance writer who owns and operates Deluxe Copywriting, whose clients have included such names as WorkFusion and Comparitech. He has previously written for the US-based...

  • Member since 2017
  • 236 items added with 100,267 views

Top Members

Rafael Herzberg

Consultant energy affairs

Self employed

Matt Chester

Energy Analyst

Chester Energy and Policy

Noah Horowitz

Sr Engineer

Natural Resources Defense Council

WARNING: SIGN-IN

You need to be a member of Energy Central to access some features and content. Please sign-in or register to continue.

Shared Link

  • Share
  • Sign in to Vote Like (4)
  • Comment (6)
  • Sep 7, 2019 5:40 pm GMT
  • 661 views

Honestly, there's a pretty good chance you've heard this news already (due to it going viral), but it's the kind of news that deserves to be hammered home. The science is officially in—and it's delightfully symbiotic.

Crops under solar panels can be a win–win

In dry places, photovoltaic shade can even reduce water use.

Read More
Source: arstechnica.com
  • #solar
  • #plants
  • #crops
  • report
Ben Schultz's picture

Thank Ben for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.

Sign in to Vote Like this post
Follow
More posts from this member
  • First US steel plants powered by wind, solar energy are coming for industry with big carbon footprint
  • Utility commission approves 1,190 MW of new Nevada solar+storage projects
  • A $39 Billion Wind Company Bets Hydrogen Is Key to Climate Goals
  • Texas steps up their geothermal energy game with new initiatives

Discussions

Sign in to Participate

Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Sep 8, 2019 4:35 pm GMT

"Solar panel installations may not be compatible with the machinery used to harvest many crops..." 

From someone with only a rudimentary understanding of agricultural practice, solar panel installations are not compatible with the machinery used to harvest any crop.

"But there are configurations for certain crops in certain areas that can make a lot of sense."

Similarly, there are situations showing certain pigs under certain aerodynamic conditions in certain areas can fly. Aren't there?

  • Sign in or Register to post comments
Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Sep 9, 2019 12:00 pm GMT

Are you saying there are no situations in which this set up can work? Obviously it's not saying put solar panels on every part of the farm or even on every farm, but for the situations in which it works and farmers can harness even more profit from their land it's a win-win. 

  • Sign in or Register to post comments
Bob Meinetz's picture
Bob Meinetz on Sep 13, 2019 2:42 am GMT

Not at all, Matt. I'm saying there are situations where almost anything can be "set up to work". But planting crops under solar panels, where they don't get water, where they don't get sun, where they're difficult to weed, where crops are effectively impossible to harvest, where soil is effectively impossible to till, is frankly one of the stupidest ideas I've heard in a long, long time.

It's an idea thought up by someone who's never had to grow crops to feed his/her family, by some renewables advocate who is trying to justify renewables' horrendous land-use footprint, who recognizes they create real problems for real people trying to make a living. Guess what? Farming is a hard enough job as it is. Farmers work all. day. long. for next to nothing. Don't believe me? Take a solar panel on a little stand to a farm, at harvest time, and ask the farmer whether you can set your panel up in the middle of his field, and string wires back to the barn so you can charge a battery. After he finishes laughing, explain he'll have to be careful in his harvester so he won't run over your wires. By this time, he won't hear you - he's on his way back to the farmhouse to fetch his shotgun.

  • Sign in or Register to post comments
Matt Chester's picture
Matt Chester on Sep 13, 2019 11:26 am GMT

Take a solar panel on a little stand to a farm, at harvest time, and ask the farmer whether you can set your panel up in the middle of his field, and string wires back to the barn so you can charge a battery

That's a bit of a strawman argument-- the pitch of this type of setup is not to take all existing farms and plop down solar panels on top. Obviously that wouldn't work. It's talking about giving farmers an option where they can plan their land use strategically so that the panels can make sense with certain specific crops in pre-planned situations. 

The study's investigation of which crops could benefit from the shade has been done in tandem with farmers of the region (Arizona, where this study takes place, where the solar resources are most valuable to capture as well):

The farmers help the researchers decide on test crops as well. Every spring and fall they grow beans, tomatoes, and a couple of types of peppers. They grow high-value herbs and spices, showing the potential additional profits that can come from intentionally selecting crops that might not otherwise grow well in typical conditions, but that can now grow well in the shade of solar panels.

They also work with leafy greens like lettuces, chards, and kale, which seem to grow better in this system. Plants in high-light environments tend to have smaller leaves -- an adaptation for not capturing too much sunlight and overwhelming the photosynthesis system. Plants in low-light environments grow larger leaves to spread out the light-capturing chlorophyll that let plants change light to energy. The researchers are seeing that in their trials: basil plants produce larger leaves, kale leaves are longer and wider, and chard leaves are larger. This is key for these crops because farmers harvest the leafy parts of these plants.

The solar panels themselves also benefit from the co-location. In places where it is above 75 degrees Fahrenheit when sunny, solar panels begin under-performing because they become too hot. The evaporation of water from the crops creates localized cooling, which reduces heat stress on the panels overhead and boosts their performance. In short, it is a win-win-win at the food-water-energy nexus.

Having these farmers involved in desigining the study help bring to light any potential concerns:

When it comes time to harvest the crops, it is actually not a big hassle, explains Barron-Gafford, as farmers can use much of the same equipment. "We raised the panels so that they were about 3 meters (10 feet) off the ground on the low end so that typical tractors could access the site. This is was the first thing that farmers in the area said would have to be in place for them to consider any kind of adoption of an agrivoltaic system."

 

  • Sign in or Register to post comments
Matt Bowgren's picture
Matt Bowgren on Sep 9, 2019 10:15 pm GMT

Most older farmers are land rich and cash poor while younger farmers are neither, so there is an interesting economic possibility that by increasing the production of the land from non-farming sources may allow the land owners to reduce the lease price for farming,making farming more accessible to younger farmers. Regarding the machines issue, this just sounds to me like a new opportunity for equipment manufacturers to develop a solution that works well with solar installations. Manufacturers love change, because it means an opportunity to sell new equipment!

  • Sign in or Register to post comments
Ben Schultz's picture
Ben Schultz on Sep 10, 2019 5:37 am GMT

100% agree. It also makes a more efficient use of pre-exiting real estate, and it could even increase the price of farm properties.

  • Sign in or Register to post comments

Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

Start a Post »                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »

Your access to Member Features is limited.

Sign InApply for membership
  • Share a link

Group Sponsors




Become a sponsor

Related Content

Utility commission approves 1,190 MW of new Nevada solar+storage projects
70Sign in to Vote Like (1)
Achieving Beneficial Electrification in Commercial Buildings
193Sign in to Vote Like (1)
Where renewables should be installed for greater advantages
256Sign in to Vote Like (1)
92% of Americans want moAR solar power, greater than any other action Pew Research says
76Sign in to Vote Like (1)

Recent Comments

Matt Bowgren
Matt commented on ...
Getting to Know Your Expert Interview Series: Rafael Herzberg, Expert in the Energy Efficiency Community
Someone is always coming for your lunch...even the utility's.
Bob Meinetz
Bob commented on ...
‎Redefining Energy: Green Datacenters (interviews with Google and Microsoft) - dec19 on Apple Podcasts
Matt, a 2015 investigation into Apple's North Carolina Data Center, which Apple claimed was powered by "100% renewable" energy, determined only...
Victoria Hudson
Victoria commented on ...
‎Redefining Energy: Green Datacenters (interviews with Google and Microsoft) - dec19 on Apple Podcasts
Haven't listened to the podcast but am wondering if it mentions the "water-based" datacenters?
Matt Chester
Matt commented on ...
‎Redefining Energy: Green Datacenters (interviews with Google and Microsoft) - dec19 on Apple Podcasts
 learn how tech giants have become prominent drivers of the Energy Transition through their Green Power Purchasing Strategy.

Sponsors & Partners

Navigant, A Guidehouse Company
AESP
EnergyCentralJobs
Esri
Energy Central
Bentley Systems, Inc.
Atonix Digital | A Black & Veatch Company
PLMA (Peak Load Management Alliance)
Smart Electric Power Alliance (SEPA)
Oracle Utilities

Our Mission
Our mission at Energy Central is to help global power industry professionals work better. Our Power Industry Network™ platform is built to help our members connect with each other, share their knowledge & experience and advance their careers in the industry. Membership is open to professionals working at utilities and organizations supporting the industry.

Energy Central

  • Membership
  • Community Standards
  • Participate!
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us

Get Social

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook

Stay Connected

  • Subscribe
  • Follow via RSS
  • Contact Us