This group brings together the best thinkers on energy and climate. Join us for smart, insightful posts and conversations about where the energy industry is and where it is going.


Carbon is the Problem: Is Graphene the Solution?

Graphene Solution

Carbon emissions cause climate change.  Intelligent policy in the public and private sectors works to reduce CO2 emissions  – through actions as varied as the recent EPA decision to throttle back atmospheric pollution from power plants to energy efficiency programs that reduce the need for electricity.  Innovative technologies that improve grid awareness and consumer awareness of electricity consumption also help to reduce emissions and energy costs.  But in a very real sense, all of these solutions merely ameliorate the dilemmas caused by a growing global demand for energy.  The real problem is the material foundation for our modern society – silicon.

Silicon runs the world as the most common material used for semiconductors, sensors, and data storage that runs grids, communications networks, vehicles and just about everything that has a display or mobile connection.  From a Smart Grid perspective, semiconductors are used for energy collection, conversion, storage, transmission and distribution, and consumption.

Silicon is cheap and readily available – it is the second most common element found on Earth and it is easily manufactured on a large scale.   Silicon is an excellent conductor of heat and it consumes a lot of electricity – some electricity powers a semiconductor and the rest cools the components.  Power consumption is a major constraint in contemporary chip design.  And then there’s the expansion of data centers as storage centers for cloud-based solutions and engines for the internet.   A recent study* identified that global power requirements grew by 63% to 38 gigawatts (GW) from 24GW in 2011.  Cooling costs make up about 30% of the total electricity bill for large data centers.

We increasingly rely on intelligent electronics in our connected and mobile economy, which means a proliferation of silicon-based processors, memory, and sensors.  These devices are estimated to waste 15 terawatts (TW) globally now– mostly as lowgrade waste heat that cannot be captured for any other purpose (such as application in a combined heat and power system).  That number will only grow as our reliance on electricity and electronic devices increases for world populations.

So it is no surprise that the search is on to find a better material than silicon – one that is much more “energy-efficient” and less likely to produce waste heat.  Groundbreaking discoveries in materials science – the composition of things – promises a truly ironic possibility – that a different form of carbon can be a global answer instead of a global problem.  Graphite and diamonds are the two physical representations of carbon.  And while diamonds may be a girl’s best friend today, in the long run, graphite may be everyone’s best friend.  Graphene is derived from graphite.

Graphene is an unrolled carbon nanotube.  It is extremely strong, extremely flexible, and extraordinarily high thermal conductivity – meaning it does not produce the heat buildup like that produced in things made from silicon.  Carbon is the 15th most commonly occurring element – it is not a rare earth material.  This video provides the best explanation of graphene.

Graphene has interesting potential as a replacement for silicon.  Not only can it “run cooler” than silicon, but it also has versatility to perform as a good energy harvesting material too.   It’s attracting R&D investments ranging from $1.3 USD committed by the European Commission to increased funding by companies such as IBM and Samsung.  Of course, R&D activity is a far cry from commercially available products, but we’ve seen the same path trodden for many innovations – such as solar photovoltaics.  What initially is expensive and difficult to scale up and cost-effectively manufacture startles all observers with its rapid pace of technology advances and cost reductions.

Will graphene replace silicon?  If it can perform just as well with a lower energy demand than silicon, then the answer is probably yes.  If it can perform better than silicon with lower energy demand, then the answer is absolutely yes.  And if that’s the case, it is one technology that will be just as disruptive to manufacturers and solution providers as it will be to utilities.

*  DatacenterDynamics 2012 Global Census

Photo Credit: Graphene a Carbon Solution?/shutterstock

Christine Hertzog's picture

Thank Christine for the Post!

Energy Central contributors share their experience and insights for the benefit of other Members (like you). Please show them your appreciation by leaving a comment, 'liking' this post, or following this Member.


Jessee McBroom's picture
Jessee McBroom on Oct 31, 2013 4:38 pm GMT

Thanks for the post Christine. In answer to your question; I do believe graphene and other forms of carbon composites will prove to be the solution to many problems associated with the silicon based electronics. The field of graphene based electronics is really starting to make significant advances and achievements.

Robert Bernal's picture
Robert Bernal on Nov 1, 2013 5:33 am GMT

I think that the single most important use for graphine or carbon nanotubes (the rolled up version) is the development of a space elevator. Silicon switching devices are already on the order of the 90+ % efficiencies. Thus, conserving an extra percent or so is “nothing” compared to the clean energy potential of cheap space access (such as solar power satelites) and the continuing and expanded vision (and hope) such a robust space program would offer.

However, I like your post and agree that we must research anything graphene!

Meltdown proof nuclear is needed to replace fossil fuels in a growing world. Perhaps further research into graphene could help on this front, but eventually, solar power satelites could even obsolete this awesome form of nuclear!

David Newell's picture
David Newell on Nov 14, 2013 3:41 am GMT
Carbon is the Problem: Is Graphene the Solution?


I think the article “title” is misleading, as the way in which “Carbon” is a problem, has exactly zero to do with the application of graphene to semiconductor technology.


Unless of course, there is a premise to capture 50 billion tons of CO2 and make semiconductors.

Roger Arnold's picture
Roger Arnold on Mar 18, 2014 8:52 pm GMT

The title probably is misleading.  So are the headlines on tabloid news stories.  They serve similar fundtions.

I think Christine is correct, though, to focus on the potential of graphene for very low-power electronics. Have you ever visited a data center?  Multiple megawatts of heat dissipation.  For that matter, if you’re a “typical” American living in a temperate area with low air conditioning needs, probably a third to as much as half of your monthly electric bill is for power consumed by electronic gadgets and the chargers and power converters to run them.

Roger Arnold's picture
Roger Arnold on Mar 18, 2014 9:10 pm GMT

Good job of putting the issue in context.  One point though:

Two of the biggest potential energy savings associated with ongoing advances in electronics are indirect. Cheap broadband communications, sensors, and actuators may finally begin to usher in the era of telecommuting and remote presence.  That will reduce travel.  And when we do travel, semi-autonamous vehicles with enough “situational awareness” to preclude crashes will enable lighter and more efficient cars and scooters.  

Small, efficient “personal electric vehicles” would be a much easier sell if one could eliminate the risk  of being clobbered by an inattentive driver.


Get Published - Build a Following

The Energy Central Power Industry Network is based on one core idea - power industry professionals helping each other and advancing the industry by sharing and learning from each other.

If you have an experience or insight to share or have learned something from a conference or seminar, your peers and colleagues on Energy Central want to hear about it. It's also easy to share a link to an article you've liked or an industry resource that you think would be helpful.

                 Learn more about posting on Energy Central »