Land of Ten Thousand Turbines?

Posted on August 25, 2009
Posted By: Jake Rasweiler
Topic: Wind
Wind generators and wireless networks are poised to push Minnesota to the lead among renewable integrators

Minnesota is known as the "land of ten thousand lakes." Given the rapid growth of the state's renewable energy sector will it soon become the "land of ten thousand turbines?" More than 1400 wind turbines now generate 1800 MW of electricity -- providing 7.5 percent of the state's power. Renewable market experts rank the state ninth in the nation for wind energy potential, yet Minnesota currently ranks fourth in the country for installed wind power capacity.

Under the state's renewable energy objective, among the most ambitious in the nation, 25 percent of the state's power must be provided by renewables by the year 2025. To meet this goal, Minnesota will need to install another 5,000 MW of capacity over the next 15 years according to Mark Rathbun, who is the Renewable Energy Project Leader for Great River Energy, one of the state's leading utilities. This aggressive goal exceeds the national target set by the U.S. Department of Energy of 20 percent by 2030.

Monitoring Wind Output

Like any large energy project, building a wind plant is a complex undertaking. It involves balancing issues that include proximity to transmission lines, securing access to capital, and negotiating site, zoning, and environmental permits. One factor given relatively little publicity is communication. Modern next-generation wind turbines are much more complex than older models, and they require constant monitoring to optimize output and maximize revenue. Turbine manufacturers, developers, and operators measure dozens of statistics at each turbine location, including electric output and mechanical and hydraulic factors like yaw, noise, and pitch. This constant stream of data requires high-performance communications.

New Communications Challenges

Fiber optic communications has been an established norm in the domestic wind industry for years, but that paradigm could shift as other technology alternatives mature. Globally, wireless communication systems are as likely to be utilized as fiber. As international and more experienced wind developers and owners bring projects to the American market, the use of wireless technology for data transmission will become more common.

Wireless has inherent advantages over other forms of landline communication. Foremost is its ability to avoid trenching and re-trenching costs. Once the wireless cloud is in the air, any moves, additions or changes can be done without dispatching the backhoe. Maintenance is easier than fiber optic cable. Gophers don't eat it. Backhoes can't run over it. And wireless avoids the considerable damage and deterioration that naturally occurs with fiber. Wireless also supports mobility workforce applications and provides coverage both inside and outside a wind plant on the same uniform network.

Wireless Case Studies

In Minnesota, wireless communications already supports wind farms. These farms are part of one of the nation's largest smart grid networks (and perhaps the only state-wide smart grid network in the country). This high availability, high-speed, private network was built for Great River Energy and its member co-operatives. It supports NIST communications and security standards, such as DNP3.0, 802.x, 802.11, IPSEC, and SSL, and provides high-speed connectivity to over 16 utilities operating a variety of smart grid applications, including mesh and PLC based AMR/AMI, SCADA, video surveillance, VoIP, and remote workforce management.

The American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) named Great River Energy 2009 "Rural Electric Cooperative Utility of the Year" for being the electric co-op using the most wind in the United States. Great River Energy purchases power from six different wind plants, totaling 318 megawatts. Several of its sub-stations, each equipped with a wireless modem, serve as junction points for the transmission of turbine data. Arcadian Networks provides the network backbone for 535 sub-stations located throughout Great River Energy's 56,000 square mile service area. Currently, wind plants are incurring the cost and limitations of using fiber optic cable to transmit data into the grid. Whether this arrangement will continue depends upon the continuing evolution of wireless. The innovative use of wireless technologies in Minnesota is paving a new path and creating a strategically relevant business model for the use of wireless networks as a primary carrier of wind data.

Beyond Minnesota

With 28 states now mandating renewable portfolio standards, and new North American Electricity Reliability Corporation (NERC) standards calling for ten minute forecasting requirements, wireless solutions that allow independent turbine readings and off-site weather readings will soon become an operational necessity. The move to wireless is a "natural and beneficial progression" according to Ed Solar, CEO of Arcadian Networks.

The roll-out in Minnesota of a private, standards-based, wireless broadband data network allowing plug-and-play connections may be particularly appropriate for their needs. Not only does it deliver communications across sparsely populated rural areas of the country, but use of licensed, protected spectrum provides security benefits far greater than unlicensed frequencies used in the public domain. The networks are NERC/FERC compatible, fully secure and encrypted, and use ruggedized equipment with proven ability to withstand the harshest weather. Utilities throughout the nation's wind corridor, from the Midwest to the Dakotas to Texas, will soon be implementing their own communication networks. Will what's working in Minnesota apply throughout the wind belt?

Authored By:
As Vice President of Engineering and Network Operations, Jake delivers the highest level of expertise drawn from more than twenty years in both business process and engineering specialties. Jake's leadership in wireless network design, site development, field operations, and construction has made him a respected thought leader. His writings -- on urban network design, microcell technology, critical infrastructure communications and more -- have appeared in utility trade publications worldwide. He

Related Posts



August, 25 2009

Harry Valentine says

There is great potential to develop cost-competitive wind energy technology, including airborne and towerless wind power technologies. Many of the concerns that relate to wind power have solutions . . . there are wind turbine designs that are harmless to birds and bats and that generate little or no noise. One of the great challenges of wind technology is to develop energy storage technology that can accomodate the combined output of thousands of turbines.

August, 25 2009

James Carson says

As a lifelong resident of Minnesota, I can tell you that the situation is not quite as rosy as Mr. Rasweiler implies. There are several problems, mostly pertaining to transmission. NIMBY is a serious issue wrt transmission everywhere. Not like Minnesota, however. There is a history here of violent opposition to new transmission. Over the past four decades, there have been several instances of severe vandalism in the state against power lines that would be classified as terrorism today.

CAPX 2020 is the current initiative to bring the grid here to modern standards. If successful, this initiative will relieve the worst congestion points in the US (outside the northeast). The state PUC is slowly grinding through this initiative and may complete their work over the next decade to meet local needs, including wind integration.

Moreover, there is an ADDITIONAL initiative (link below) that has begun to move forward. Just this past week, an initiative was launched to study transmission alternatives from the Dakotas through the Upper Midwest to points east. You may notice that there are no Minnesota companies involved despite the fact that any such transmission projects will necessarily traverse the state. By my reckoning, the initiative will require several 345kv lines. I have pointed this out to several friends and their universal response was: "Yeah... Right... Good luck with that one."

August, 26 2009

Jeff Presley says

Jake, could you clarify this statement from your article? More than 1400 wind turbines now generate 1800 MW of electricity -- providing 7.5 percent of the state's power What I'd like to know is whether the 7.5% is what is GENERATED or what is AVAILABLE as a percentage of capacity?

August, 26 2009

James Carson says

It's actually generated megawatthours.

August, 28 2009

Len Gould says

So a land of 10,000 (wind) turbines would also be a land of many hundreds of gas turbines also. How's Minesotta's Natural Gas reserves?

August, 29 2009

James Carson says

Our natgas reserves are nil. However, North Dakota is next door. So, no problem.

September, 01 2009

Don Hirschberg says

I notice Jeff's question (which would have been mine) was answered by James, not by Jake to whom it was addressed..

James, does your answer cover a significant time period, such as a year? 7.5% is very impressive.

September, 02 2009

nabil hamdi says

File Name: (WIND):

I may turn you the world leader in: (Wind/wave/tide)-technologies. =============================================== Dipl. Engineer Nabil Mostafa

Birth date 27th Nov. 1939 E-mail Cairo, egypt

(Scientific inventions)_: Adopt, patent, finance, produce & market:

Engineering/Aerospace/ Helicopters/Airframes/ [for Marine, and land: 100++MW highest efficiency environmentally friendly low speed giant diesel units] /Naval/high power-density propellers/ Submarines/Fisheries/OffshoreOil/Automotive/Transportation/ Bikes/Defense-Military/Civil/Snow-Roofs/ Shore breakwater/Ultimate piles and Diaphragms/Fast deep pier caissons/ Flood Rescue Countermeasures- Integrator/Structures/Renewables/Electrodynamics/ Hydrodynamics/New Sports of Olympic Tendency/Clubs/Entertainment/House Hold stuffs/Tourism/Musical-instruments/Toys/Arts/Collectibles/some rural and urban development concepts/handicapped-some needy gadget/Science-Museums/Cartography/sustainability/etc.

I may license all free only to the government departments which may sponsor

Very new concepts and design principles to ideally harvest (Wind power): (HAWT) and (VAWT), featuring all: -------------------------------------------------------------------- -Extraordinary generator (design/construction)-principles.

-Slip Rings (sparkless), durable/reliable

-Inherently highly-(mitigated/damped) noise levels.

-Highly-resilient (gear-meshing)-principles: (Design/construction/materials).

-plenty modifications for the existing giant multi-MW turbines.

-New (blades): Both for Windturbines and (Helicopters main rotor blades): (Theory, design, construction, and materials).

-Regulation Methods: (VP, Stall, brake, yaw and Sail).

-New (Nacelle-Theory).

-New (Hub-Theory).

-New Transmission Concepts

-Distributed-(peak-peckers): (integrated-complexes) theory/design.

- (Lightning arresters) for the park: (new theory).

-plenty hurricane Protection concepts.

-New Anemometry Principles and Schemes.

-plenty designs of giant: Meteorological-(down-swinging poles).

-Hybrid-(OWC): Oscillating Water-Column Principles

-OWC: modern designs of: air-Tunnels and airturbines.

-Wind-powered-vehicles: [Paved-Land, ice/sand, marine and amphibious]: For (Sports, competition, entertainment and amusement).

- (Autonomous Ocean Wave Energy Converters).

- (Wind/Wave/Tide-currents) Energy Converters

-Several [Modern Renewable Energy Schemes]: Could be fulfilled at Shipbuilders and sheet metal fabricators As an added new business, And to multiply the number of players in the market, Ex-shed production lines.

-Abandoned offshore platforms: TLP, and Spars, turned into: (Wave/wind)-unprecedented Energy Converter concepts, Plus (Tourism/scientific research) -Visits

-Ditto; for my highly developed and engineered Integrated Shoreline-Breakwater Designs: (the same as above)

-Miniaturized (toy-sized) turbines, inviting brand toy Producers to supply: (Global science museums)-market industry type, And collectibles. Also standing as economical demonstrators For the mother very new prototypes-concepts of my Invention items, and for International events.

- (CCS): Carbon Capture and Storage under seafloor: Extraordinary modern gas pumping system: High efficiency, durable, Fast wear compensators/adjusters

-Seafloor Multi-phase Pumping System, durable, Automatic Fast wear compensators/adjusters, Handling mixed percentages at once of: Oil, gas, water, high percentage of sand safely, than Other existing pump types ============================================= (((TECHNOLOGIES of the coming future MAY ACT NOW))) I may afford a single Windturbine unit concept of generation capacity unprecedented, over: (10++ MW): onshore/offshore applications. Plenty of my preliminary tests are designed without the need to the costly and permanently busy WINDTUNNELS, saving greet time too. ====================================================== Any of my items holding the name as existing counterparts but will be fully different in every thing like if you try to find the difference between a bicycle and a boat. How could you compare?! =============================================== E-mail

September, 02 2009

James Carson says

Don: I think they get that number by applying the average capacity factor to the wind capacity to get total mwh, and then taking that as a percentage of annual mwh. Capacity factors here are in the low 30s.

Add your comments:

Please log in to leave a comment!
back to top

Receive Energy Central eNews & Updates


Navigant's Energy Market Outlook and Industry Trends: A View of the Energy Industry Going Forward

Thursday Oct 6, 2016 - 12:00 PM Eastern - Virtual Event

The energy industry is experiencing unprecedented change. It is an exciting time as the industry reshapes and redefines itself. Changes affecting the markets and industry are wide-ranging. This presentation will look at the effects of these fundamental and structural changes more...

Sponsored Content